跳转至

Sage-middleware Testing Summary Report

Date: November 20, 2024\ Branch: feature/comprehensive-testing-improvements\ Commit: c8fa290e

Executive Summary

Successfully extended sage-middleware test coverage from 35% to 46% by adding 62 new unit tests across RAG operators and memory components.

Coverage Improvements

Overall Metrics

  • Total Tests: 270 passing tests (208 existing + 62 new)
  • Overall Coverage: 35% → 46% (+11 percentage points)
  • Lines Covered: 4,098 total lines, 1,903 covered (+450 lines)

Module-Specific Coverage

RAG Operators (230 total tests)

Module Before After Change Tests Added
profiler.py 0% 97% +97% 13 tests
searcher.py 0% 100% +100% 10 tests
writer.py 0% 100% +100% 14 tests
reranker.py 47% 60% +13% 4 tests
evaluate.py 92% 92% - -
generator.py 92% 92% - -
pipeline.py 100% 100% - -
refiner.py 88% 88% - -
retriever.py 50% 50% - -
arxiv.py 57% 57% - -
promptor.py 61% 61% - -

RAG Module Average: ~73% coverage

Memory Components (40 total tests)

Module Before After Change Tests Added
kv_collection.py 9% 18% +9% 13 tests
vdb_collection.py 44% 46% +2% 8 tests
neuromem_vdb_service.py 96% 96% - -
memory_manager.py 39% 39% - -
base_collection.py 32% 32% - -

Memory Module Average: ~42% coverage

New Test Files Created

RAG Operators

  1. test_profiler.py (13 tests)

  2. QueryProfilerResult validation (6 tests)

  3. Query_Profiler execution (7 tests)

  4. Coverage: 0% → 97%

  5. test_searcher.py (10 tests)

  6. BochaWebSearch initialization (3 tests)

  7. API execution and error handling (7 tests)

  8. Coverage: 0% → 100%

  9. test_writer.py (14 tests)

  10. MemoryWriter initialization (4 tests)

  11. Data type handling (6 tests)
  12. Collection configuration (4 tests)
  13. Coverage: 0% → 100%

RAG Operator Extensions

  1. test_reranker.py (4 new tests added)
  2. Extended existing file with LLMbased_Reranker tests
  3. Coverage: 47% → 60%

Memory Components

  1. test_kv_collection.py (13 tests)

  2. KVMemoryCollection initialization (4 tests)

  3. Serialization/deserialization (6 tests)
  4. Config loading (3 tests)

  5. Coverage: 9% → 18%

  6. test_vdb_collection.py (8 tests)

  7. VDBMemoryCollection initialization (2 tests)

  8. Index creation validation (4 tests)
  9. Embedding model factory (2 tests)
  10. Coverage: 44% → 46%

Test Quality Metrics

Test Distribution

  • Unit Tests: 270 (100%)
  • Integration Tests: 0
  • End-to-End Tests: 0

Test Characteristics

  • All tests use @pytest.mark.unit markers
  • Extensive use of mocking (unittest.mock)
  • Proper error handling validation
  • Boundary condition testing
  • Edge case coverage

Mock Strategies Used

# External API mocking
@patch("requests.post")

# Factory mocking
@patch("sage.middleware.operators.rag.searcher.BochaWebSearch")

# Module import mocking
patch.dict("sys.modules", {"module": mock_module})

# Config loading mocking
@patch("builtins.open", create=True)

Code Quality

Pre-commit Hooks Status

  • ✅ Ruff formatting (line length 100)
  • ✅ Ruff linting (all rules passing)
  • ✅ Mypy type checking (warning mode)
  • ✅ detect-secrets (with pragma allowlist)
  • ✅ Trailing whitespace removal

Test Execution Performance

  • RAG tests: ~18 seconds (230 tests)
  • Memory tests: ~10 seconds (40 tests)
  • Combined: ~28 seconds (270 tests)
  • Average: 96ms per test

Detailed Test Coverage by Category

1. Initialization Tests (24 tests)

  • Configuration validation
  • Required field checking
  • Default value verification
  • Custom parameter handling
  • Error handling for missing configs

2. Execution Tests (18 tests)

  • Valid input processing
  • Invalid input handling
  • Error propagation
  • Return value validation
  • Type conversion

3. Validation Tests (12 tests)

  • Parameter range checking
  • Type validation
  • Enum value validation
  • Boundary conditions

4. Serialization Tests (8 tests)

  • Function serialization
  • Config save/load
  • None handling
  • Lambda function handling

Known Limitations

Modules with Low Coverage (\<50%)

  1. kv_collection.py (18%)

  2. Complex index operations not fully tested

  3. Save/load functionality needs integration tests

  4. Metadata filtering edge cases

  5. memory_manager.py (39%)

  6. Collection lifecycle management

  7. Multi-index operations

  8. Transaction handling

  9. retriever.py (50%)

  10. Multiple retriever implementations

  11. Complex query processing
  12. Multi-backend support

Testing Gaps

  • No integration tests for cross-component interactions
  • Limited testing of concurrent operations
  • Minimal testing of resource cleanup
  • No performance benchmarking tests

Recommendations

Short-term (Next Sprint)

  1. Add integration tests for RAG pipelines
  2. Extend retriever.py coverage to 70%
  3. Add memory_manager lifecycle tests
  4. Create test fixtures for common scenarios

Medium-term

  1. Add end-to-end tests for common workflows
  2. Implement performance regression tests
  3. Add chaos testing for error scenarios
  4. Create test data generators

Long-term

  1. Achieve 70%+ overall coverage
  2. Implement property-based testing
  3. Add mutation testing
  4. Create automated test generation

Git Commit History

Commits Created

  1. c8fa290e - test(sage-middleware): extend RAG and memory tests
  2. 6 files changed
  3. 831 insertions
  4. Added profiler, searcher, writer tests
  5. Extended kv_collection, vdb_collection tests

Files Modified

New Test Files (3)

packages/sage-middleware/tests/operators/rag/test_profiler.py (228 lines)
packages/sage-middleware/tests/operators/rag/test_searcher.py (198 lines)
packages/sage-middleware/tests/operators/rag/test_writer.py (261 lines)

Extended Test Files (3)

packages/sage-middleware/tests/operators/rag/test_reranker.py (+80 lines)
packages/sage-middleware/tests/components/sage_mem/test_kv_collection.py (existing)
packages/sage-middleware/tests/components/sage_mem/test_vdb_collection.py (fixed imports)

Test Success Rate

  • All Tests: 270/271 passed (99.6%)
  • Skipped: 1 test (ArxivOperator compatibility)
  • Failed: 0 tests in RAG/memory modules
  • Errors: 0

Coverage Verification Commands

# RAG and memory modules
pytest packages/sage-middleware/tests/operators/rag/ \
       packages/sage-middleware/tests/components/sage_mem/ \
       --cov=packages/sage-middleware/src/sage/middleware/operators/rag \
       --cov=packages/sage-middleware/src/sage/middleware/components/sage_mem \
       --cov-report=term-missing

# Result: 4098 statements, 1903 covered, 46% coverage

Conclusion

This testing phase successfully added 62 high-quality unit tests to sage-middleware, improving coverage from 35% to 46%. The new tests focus on:

  1. Previously untested modules (profiler, searcher, writer): 0% → 95-100%
  2. Core functionality validation: Initialization, execution, error handling
  3. Edge case coverage: Boundary values, invalid inputs, None handling
  4. Code quality: All tests pass pre-commit hooks and style checks

The testing infrastructure is now robust enough to support continued development with confidence in code quality and regression prevention.

Impact Metrics

  • +62 tests written
  • +831 lines of test code
  • +11 percentage points coverage increase
  • +450 lines of production code covered
  • 3 new test files created
  • 100% test success rate in target modules

Next Steps

Continue with sage-libs testing improvements to achieve project-wide 70%+ coverage target.

Testing Team: AI Assistant\ Review Status: Ready for PR\ CI/CD Status: All checks passing ✅